San Mateo Highlands · Sale Report

2220 Allegheny Way Sells for $2,252,250 — What It Means for San Mateo Highlands Values

Published September 4, 2026 · San Mateo Highlands

2220 Allegheny Way, an Eichler in the San Mateo Highlands neighborhood, closed on August 25, 2024 for $2,252,250 — $1349 per square foot.

The numbers

Sale price$2,252,250
Beds / Baths4 bd / 2.00 ba
Square feet1,670
Price / sqft$1349
Year built1957

What it means for San Mateo Highlands

That sits $120/sqft below the trailing two-year San Mateo Highlands average of $1469/sqft. This is one of 49 recorded San Mateo Highlands sales in the trailing two years.

Every recent sale, every $/sqft comp, and every home in the neighborhood is indexed on the San Mateo Highlands community page.

Own an Eichler in San Mateo Highlands?

This sale just reset the comp set for your street. If you have ever wondered what number would make you move, set a private Make Me Move price — no listing, no open houses, no public record — and claim a $5,000 account credit toward your next deal through McMullen Properties.

Claim your $5K credit →